1.Humans are social animals, require deep social connections in order to thrive, and develop much of their sense of self through the social environment they’re raised in. Humans cannot live well in isolation, and live best when working together within a framework of mutual respect and reciprocity.
2.Big government is the only political system compatible with (1).
3.Libertarians oppose big government.
4.Therefore libertarians reject (1).
It is a nonstarter. For every supposed refutation I have heard of caution when approaching more government, I have never seen someone fully grasp the argument that big government is a bad idea…